How to justify a view
NESA defines it as: “Support an argument or conclusion.”
Justify asks you to give the reasons a position holds. You are usually handed a statement and asked to defend it, so the marker is watching for a case that is built rather than asserted.
New here first? Start with breaking down the whole question, then come back for this.
Build the case, close the objection
Justifying is advocacy: you argue for a position and defend it against its best counter.
- 1
State the position plainly
Commit to the claim you must defend, so the argument has a clear target.
- 2
Stack the reasons
Give each paragraph a fresh, evidenced reason to agree, building the case.
- 3
Answer the strongest objection
Defend the view against its best counter, rather than the weakest.
The shape of the paragraph
The paragraph gives a reason, evidences it, then defends it against the obvious objection.
Topic sentence (a reason)
Open with a clear reason that supports the position you are defending.
Watch out:A reason, not a restatement. Move the case forward with each topic sentence.
Evidence for it
Ground the reason in a quote and work the Explanation.
Watch out:Keep the analysis pointed at supporting the claim, not analysing for its own sake.
Address the counter
Raise the strongest objection and show why it fails.
Watch out:Meet the real counter, so the defence looks earned rather than convenient.
Return line (the earned position)
Restate the position, now supported and defended.
Watch out:Sound like the case is closed, rather than still open.
A model paragraph, labelled sentence by sentence
Here is the structure at work. Read the paragraph straight through first: it should sound like one continuous argument, not a checklist. Then read the label beside each sentence to see the job it is doing. It is written to support this thesis:
The thesis
Proctor's death is a triumph rather than a defeat, because by choosing to die with his name intact he wins the one victory the court cannot take from him: the integrity of the self.
The paragraph, read straight through
Proctor's death reads as a triumph because it is the first moment he acts wholly from conscience rather than fear. Tearing up the confession, he chooses to die declaring “I have given you my soul; leave me my name!”, the contrast of soul against name placing integrity above survival itself. In refusing to buy his life with a lie, he reclaims the honesty his affair had cost him. It might be objected that dying achieves nothing against the court, yet this mistakes the play's measure of victory: Proctor defeats the court not by outliving it but by denying it the false confession it needs to justify itself. His death therefore stands as a triumph of the self over a power that could take his life but never his name.
Proctor's death reads as a triumph because it is the first moment he acts wholly from conscience rather than fear.
Tearing up the confession, he chooses to die declaring “I have given you my soul; leave me my name!”, the contrast of soul against name placing integrity above survival itself.
In refusing to buy his life with a lie, he reclaims the honesty his affair had cost him.
It might be objected that dying achieves nothing against the court, yet this mistakes the play's measure of victory: Proctor defeats the court not by outliving it but by denying it the false confession it needs to justify itself.
His death therefore stands as a triumph of the self over a power that could take his life but never his name.
Every quotation above is verbatim from The Crucible (Arthur Miller) and verified against the source text.
See it done on your own paragraph
Paste your essay and we will show you, sentence by sentence, where your writing stops short, and rewrite your own lines toward Band 6. Free, about a minute.
Mark my essay — free →The other key words
Back to all the key words, or learn the techniques that give you something to write about.
The definition is quoted from NESA's Glossary of Key Words. The structure, teaching and model paragraph are our own, aligned to the 2017 English Advanced syllabus (2019–2026 prescriptions).